How to Tackle Just One Card

In an earlier post I laid out six different strategies you could use to get your debt under control. Today we’re digging into the first one: paying off just one card first.

Within that approach you have two choices. You can either target the card charging the highest interest rate, or the card with the highest utilization rate.

I know, I know — you’re probably asking yourself what on earth a utilization rate even is. Don’t worry, I’ll break it down shortly.

First, compare your interest rates:

Pull one statement for each of your credit cards, or sign in to your online banking and download a digital copy of each statement.

Depending on your issuer, the statement should include a column showing your payment due date, minimum payment, balance as of the statement date, previous balance and interest rate. Ignore the rest of those figures for now and zero in on the interest rates.

Here’s how that looks on my Scotiabank statements:

As you can see, my AMEX card had* a far higher interest rate than my VISA.

Next, look at your utilization rates:

To work out your utilization rate, divide the balance on your credit card by that card’s limit. Here’s an example:

My AMEX had a final balance of $5,035.66 against a limit of $5,000.

5,035.66 ÷ 5,000 = 1.00%

My VISA had a final balance of $3,540.26 against a limit of $5,500.

3,540.26 ÷ 5,500 = 0.64%

The card with the highest utilization rate is probably doing the most harm to your credit score, while the card with the highest interest rate is costing your bank account the most.

Because my AMEX carried both the higher interest rate and the higher utilization rate, I knew it was the card to attack first. It was wrecking my credit, and the minimum payments were big enough to take a serious bite out of my bank account every month.

Review your cards along with their interest and utilization rates. Decide which matters more for you and your situation, then concentrate on paying off just one card for now.

Don’t neglect your other credit cards, though! Keep making payments on them, even if it’s only the minimum for now. Once the balance on your focus card comes down, it becomes easier to start adding extra payments to ALL of your cards.

Next time I’ll cover option two. Options one and two work hand in hand, so stay tuned!

*I no longer have the AMEX card.

Leave a comment

Whichever card you choose, the key is to keep the rest of your accounts in good standing while you focus your extra money in one place. Comparing interest and utilization rates side by side makes that decision far less overwhelming.